Free school meal pupils outnumbered 4:1 by the privately educated at grammar schools

Released 08/11/2013

Grammar school intake is skewed and children from disadvantaged backgrounds are losing out, says report

Grammar schools are four times more likely to admit private school children than those on free school meals, according to a report by the Institute for Fiscal Studies.

The report, sponsored by the Sutton Trust, found that in selective local authorities, 3% of grammar school entrants were eligible for free school meals. At other state schools, the figure is 17.5%, the Guardian reports.

At the other end of the spectrum, grammar schools were admitting 12.7% of their children from outside the state sector, largely from independent schools, the report said. On average, 6% of primary school children are enrolled in a private school nationally.

The findings, which form part of a larger report, Poor Grammar: Entry into Grammar Schools for disadvantaged pupils in England, indicate that even after allowing for "a wider range of factors that may depress pupils' academic achievement", sizeable differences remain between entrance rates.

The report added that on other measures of deprivation, the differences in admission "extended up the income scale".

"Four per cent of pupils in grammar schools live in the poorest fifth of neighbourhoods, around 21% come from the middle quintile and 34% live in the richest fifth of neighbourhoods," it said.

The chairman of the National Grammar Schools Association, Robert McCartney QC, dismissed the report, saying he did "not see anything significant in these conclusions".

He said there was "phenomenal competition" for the handful of grammar school places and after producing some of the best GCSE and A-level results in the UK, they had become a victim of their own success, which could explain discrepancies in admittance rates.

"You get a preponderance of aspirational parents [applying], particularly from the middle classes," he said, adding that these families often apply from outside areas where there were no grammar schools, further skewing figures.

He also criticised the free school meals measure. "As a yardstick for social deprivation, it is generally recognised as a crude instrument ... A number of families, particularly aspirational parents who are not well off, do not apply for free school meals.

"The type of parent who applies to grammar school, whether working class, middle-class whatever, are aspirational. They are parents who ... are determined to get the best education possible as they see it, for their children," he said.

"Many, many parents from deprived areas, including what is generally called the dependency classes, are essentially not particularly interested in any form of academic education. Their interests are directed towards pop culture, sports."

The report's author, Anna Vignoles, said the numbers coming into grammar schools from outside the state sector were "extremely high".

She said: "Even if you took two identical kids, with similar levels of achievement, and they're both coming from a state school, it's still the case that the child on free school meals is significantly less likely to get into the grammar school."


See more news stories like this


  • Anon
  • 2013-11-08 10:18:40
  • The article/report does not appear to account for the fact that children with private school backgrounds receive a greater amount of preparation for 11+ exams/assessments and hence have a greater chance of getting into grammar schools. The report is wrong in linking free school meals with grammar school entry stats as it is implying that grammar schools use free school meals (directly linked to wealth) as a deciding factor. Everyone knows and expects those with better resources (ie private schools) will help to prepare children more for 11+ exams/assessments (but what the report doesn't mention is that the wealthier children are more likely to receive additional paid for coaching outside of school to prepare for entry exams). The fiscal report is simply confirming what people know/expect.
  • andyp
  • 2013-11-08 10:31:02
  • Could it be the case that wealthier parents are more likely to be of an above average IQ and therefore their children will be as well?
  • バーバリー ストール
  • 2013-11-23 06:51:12
  • 男性バーバリー マフラー 渋谷,バーバリー 腕時計 アウトレット,バーバリー 時計 東京, バーバリー アウトレット ベビー服,バーバリー アンダーウェア,バーバリーブラックレーベル レザージャケット,バーバリー ビジネスバッグ 楽天,バーバリー ブルーレーベル ショルダー ...
  • バーバリー ダッフルコート
  • 2013-11-26 17:30:16
  • ホテルでフラワーアレンジメントを体験してみませんか? 2014 ローズコートのおせち. 2014年のおせち ご予約開始しました!! 期間限定 ヘルシー会席. 日本料理「比翼」季節限定メニュー、昨年大好評いただいた『ヘルシー会席』の再登場です!!
  • ゴヤール バッグ
  • 2013-11-27 11:06:59
  • モノグラムと悩みましたが、モノグラムはやっぱりヌメ革の染みや汚れがだんだん気になってくるので、汚れの目立たないダミエにしましたo(^-^)o
  • モンクレール 2014
  • 2013-11-27 12:29:23
  • この冬、多くの人が同じブランドのダウンを着ていた。モンクレールだ。10万円前後以上 と高価格ながら買えない人が続出し、プレミア価格が付くのはもちろんのこと、偽造品も 出回る始末だった。
  • モンブラン ボールペン 人気
  • 2013-12-02 06:12:19
  • それを考えると、モンブランの製品は長年使用しても安心できますね。
  • モンブラン 万年筆
  • 2013-12-02 11:22:10
  • モンブランが誇るソウルメーカーの一人のある女性を紹介しよう。
  • モンクレール ダウン メンズ 人気
  • 2014-01-15 09:23:00
  • モンクレール通販. そのような便利なモンクレール メンズコート冬のコート、モンクレール メンズコートなどの製品は、新しい情報に満ちている。我々は、モンクレール メンズコート で製品をご紹介します。

Share this page!

Comment on this story


Send this to a friend